Fat Tuesday: Fatty Fat Fat McFatterson
Black and blue print blouse from Lane Bryant, black skirt from Target, black China doll shoes from museumreplicas.com.
[First, an apology for my unexplained absence last week. I took Labor Day off of work, which (as I should have expected) threw off my whole concept of days. Tuesday felt like Monday, and by the time I realized that Tuesday was actually Tuesday, I needed to go to bed. Le sigh.]
So, a friend of mine was trying to describe me to someone who had met me once but couldn’t recall me. The person to whom my friend was talking asked if I was tall and thin, to which my friend replied “no, she’s tall and fat.”
There were gasps all around. How could someone – especially someone who supposedly likes me – describe me that way, so brazenly?
My friend went on to explain that I am a size acceptance activist, and that if given the opportunity, I would describe myself in similar terms. And she’s right, of course, but I still think the shock and horror are kind of funny.
We’re so scared of this word. Fat.
When I go out to a restaurant and Bradon has already been seated, I tell the host(ess) that I’m looking for a very handsome fat man with long, curly blond hair. The looks I get are…interesting. I have yet to have someone actually say something, but I can see when I break someone’s brain with the juxtaposition of “handsome” and “fat.”
Fat. Faaaaat.
Words are so fascinating. The definitions and connotations and contexts, oh my!
Most descriptive words have connotations. If I describe someone as short, thin, and blonde, chances are that you make different assumptions about them than if I describe them as tall, muscular and brunette. It’s little things, tiny twists of ideas and prejudices and cultural expectations, but it’s there.
Of all the descriptive words, “fat” is among the most evocative. If I tell you that someone is fat, the assumptions come fast and furious. Fat people are lazy. Fat people are ugly. Fat people are jolly (or sassy, or introverted.) Fat people are gross, or messy, or unmotivated.
All this from a little, three letter word. Fat makes us uncomfortable.
So we search for euphemisms. Fat people we like are “zaftig”, or “fluffy”, or “big girls/boys”, or “plus-sized”, or “heavy.”
When, really, they’re all just fat.
Many people within the size acceptance movement have been quite passionate about reclaiming the word fat. (Marianne Kirby of the Rotund is particularly in love with the word “fat”, as well she should be.) It’s a word. It’s a descriptor, and an accurate one at that. I’m not zaftig or, heaven help me, fluffy. I’m fat. It’s awesome.
So, no, I wasn’t bothered by my friend describing me as fat, because I am fat. To pretend otherwise is both disingenuous and ridiculous. I’m fat, and tall, and I have brown hair and blue eyes and more than your average number of piercings. When someone calls me fat in an effort to hurt me, I can only laugh and reply, “Why yes, I am fat. How very observant of you!”
1itgirl
wrote on 13 September 2011 at 19:44
Yeah, I also hate the idea that in order to be healthy, one must be thin, and if one is thin, one is healthy, and if one is fat, one is unhealthy, and one cannot be healthy if one is fat.
Phew.
2taelixev
wrote on 13 September 2011 at 19:54
I’ve never considered your hair brown. I do miss our yarn chats.
3Rycrafty
wrote on 13 September 2011 at 21:05
It drives me up the wall when people refer to themselves as ‘fluffy’!
4Kitten
wrote on 13 September 2011 at 22:07
An ex’s mother had a magnet on her fridge, with a picture of a sheep, that said, “Ewe is not fat, ewe is fluffy!” I thought it was hilarious; however, I immediately discount as terminally twee anyone who describes him or herself that way. (Brings to mind “Accounts Payable Nina speaking, JUST a MOOOOment!”) But to argue (cuz it’s what I do) you ARE heavy and you ARE zaftig (if the translation means what I think it means) and you ARE big. Using any of those words is no less accurate than using “fat”.
5Carole
wrote on 14 September 2011 at 3:45
Fluffy is the most ridiculous description I have ever heard and I think people who say it are ridiculous as well. I’m fat. I say it. I can’t say I’m proud of it but I am what I am.
6itgirl
wrote on 14 September 2011 at 7:41
Oh, yeah. Fluffy is my cat. If I don’t have soft fur, I am not fluffy.