Fat Tuesday: A Plea for the Fat Knitters

Tuesday, 16 August 2011, 19:56 | Category : Fat
Tags :

 

Blue and Brown print Claudia Richard blouse from Ross, charcoal slacks from Lane Bryant, Roller Rink Aerosoles heels from shoebuy.com.

My fat knitting friends, I have a humble request for you: please put pictures of you wearing your knitted objects on Ravelry.

This is not a demand, my loves.  I really do understand the desire for privacy, the hesitation to open yourself up for criticism, and the discomfort with having photographs taken.  I don’t want to ask you to do something that you feel strongly against doing.

That being said, I lovelovelove seeing pictures of awesome fat people wearing their handknits.  Not just because I love seeing pictures of awesome fat people in general, but because seeing fat people wearing handknits gives me a better idea of what I might look like wearing that same item.

Though there are not as many plus size patterns as I might hope for (for example, there are 9,983 patterns for knitted adult cardigans on Ravelry, but only 1,448 of them are identified as plus size) the options for plus size garments are improving all the time.  A large part of this improvement can, in my opinion, be attributed to Amy Singer’s insistence that any garment pattern submitted to Knitty be sized to at least 3X for women’s items and 2X for men’s items.  Knitty is such a huge influence on the knitting community (or, at least, the online knitting community) that their submission guidelines changed the way that many patterns are designed and written.  Yay for Knitty!

So we have more plus size patterns than ever, which is awesome.  But we all know how pattern sizing usually works – the original piece is usually knit in a smallish size (usually, whatever size the designer is) and then scaled up or down with math.  The bigger sizes are rarely knit by the designer, unless zie is a bigger size hirself.  (There are exceptions!)  This can lead to some…interesting…fitting issues when a real-life fat person finally knits the pattern.

When I go looking for a sweater to knit, the first thing I do as I pore through the search results is go looking for the pictures of fat people wearing the sweater in question.  Even if the fat person in question doesn’t have the exact same body type as me, seeing the sweater on a fat person can give me an idea of where it will fit and where it won’t.  Does it gape over the breasts?  Does it hang funny on the belly?  Does it look great on apple-shaped fats but hang like a sack on hourglass-shaped fats?  Does it show off fantastic fat cleavage but make a fat ass look misshapen?  I can guess at the answers to some of these questions by looking at the sweater on thin people, but sometimes you just need to see it on a fat person to be sure.

So I go looking for the fat people, and I am often disappointed.  Sometimes no fat people have knit the pattern in question – perhaps because they’re waiting for a fat person to knit it so they can see what it looks like on a fat person.  Mmm…irony.  Some intrepid fatty will just have to take the risk and find out.

But sometimes I can see that a fat person has knit the object in question, and has posted pictures…of the item laying on a bed, or hanging on a hanger.  That’s great, but it doesn’t give me the information I’m looking for.  What does it look like on your body and, by extension, what will it look like on my body?

Be brave!  Put your gorgeous sweater on your gorgeous body and snap a picture!  Not only will you be reassuring other fat people that the sweater looks good on fatties (or, conversely, warning fatties away from a sweater that didn’t scale quite the way it was intended,) you’ll be making fat people more visible within the greater culture.  It is so, so important for us to see fat people anywhere and everywhere, living their lives, being out in the world.  It seems like such a small thing, but posting a picture of your fat body wearing a sweater that you knit can help change society’s attitudes.

Your body is perfect as it is.  You have a right to take up space, you have a right to been seen, and you have a right to show off your knitting on your very own fat body.  It looks good on the bed, but it would look great on you.

9 Comments for “Fat Tuesday: A Plea for the Fat Knitters”

  1. 1Birdsong

    This is such a right-on post! The point of Ravelry is to help other knitters and crocheters find something new and great to make, but avoid the mistakes others have already made when they worked the pattern. I agree that seeing other people in something really gives you a much better idea how it will work for you. I also think all garment patterns should come with schematic drawings with measurements. Kudos to Knitty for having such an impact.
    PS… those are great colors for you!

  2. 2Nannette

    I love you (was that too forward? LOL) and I love this post!

    I’m fat and have yet to knit myself a sweater just because I haven’t seen many sweaters I like knit for heavier people. I don’t want to invest the time/money into a sweater that I have no clue if it will fit, let alone look ok. I hope more people take your post to heart and post pix of beautiful-them in their beautiful sweaters! I will (if I ever knit a sweater =P~)

  3. 3Olena

    I love love LOVE that blouse. Does it look that good up close too?

  4. 4Carole

    Generally I do post pictures of myself wearing the stuff I make for myself. When I don’t it’s mostly because I don’t have a photographer who takes pictures the way I want them taken so I wind up shooting the item myself with a tripod and remote. That takes a LOT of time but it’s worth it.

  5. 5Leslie

    I agree with your post, and additionally wish Ravelry let you sort results by size made. If I want to see how the pattern looks on someone my size, please don’t make me scroll through pages and pages of skinny chicks – I already KNOW it looks good on them.

  6. 6naomi

    Since I’m finally, finally knitting something other than a sock that is affected by my size: if, when I finish this sweater, I don’t post a modelled photo, poke at me until I do.

    (That is, good post, you’ve convinced me. Because it’s good for me to remind myself that I’m worth photographing sometimes, as uncomfortable as it can be.)

  7. 7alittleweirdo

    Just wanted to say thanks for your posts! I finally went to Lane Bryant the other day on a quest for more work clothes, and had more fun trying on clothes than I had in awhile! I can sometimes buy things at “traditional” retailers, but realized the styles at Lane Bryant are more flattering and the sales staff are friendlier. I haven’t knit any sweaters yet, since I’ve been reluctant to invest in the yarn and effort required to make one fit. But I’ve been thinking about taking a top-down sweater class. And it’s nice to know there are more plus-size patterns out there.

  8. 8Rose/yarnivore

    Thanks so much for writing this post! I can *sometimes* find someone who’s knitted the project I’m eye-ing at my size, but often not, or often, as you say, on a hanger/mannequin/bed. Doesn’t help!

    Also, I think seeing other big women looking great in their handknits is encouraging and, dare I say it, EMPOWERING. I mean, we’re the boss of our damn yarn, as Elizabeth Zimmermann used to say. Here we are making a *couture* garment. It should make us feel gorgeous and confident and happy!

    If I’m babbling, don’t mind me, I’m up *late*. :/ But I will be coming back to your blog, you can count on that!

  9. 9Rose/yarnivore

    PS — is that blouse a recent purchase? I’d love a new top something like that, and there’s a Ross right downtown. :)